Is Creator-Led Production The Answer to Sustaining and Growing TGL's Audience?
A Tale of Two Tapes – TGL League and The First Ever TGL YouTube Golf Match
The way sports content is created and consumed is evolving. Traditional live broadcasts follow a structured, high-production model, while creator-led content thrives on authenticity, engagement, and platform-first storytelling.
The big question for TGL: Can creator-led production help sustain and grow its audience when it doesn’t have Rory or Tiger playing?
It’s been a few weeks since TGL launched, and we’ve intentionally held back. Disruptive Play isn’t about chasing headlines—we focus on the deeper shifts in sports, media, and the creator economy. (For those needing a primer on TGL, plenty of perspectives exist HERE, HERE, HERE)
Today, we’re analyzing two distinct production approaches—TGL Live on ESPN vs. The First Ever TGL YouTube Golf Match by Good Good—to see what lessons can be learned from the creator-led model.
The Tale of Two Tapes: TGL Live vs. Good Good's YouTube Match
What is TGL?
TGL is a tech-driven, team-based golf competition created by TMRW Sports, co-founded by Tiger Woods and Rory McIlroy. It merges simulator golf with real-world gameplay inside a high-tech arena, aiming to modernize the sport for new audiences.
What is Good Good Golf?
Good Good Golf is a creator-led collective redefining golf content through high-energy, digital-first storytelling. Founded by influencers like Garrett Clark, Micah Morris, and Grant Horvat, Good Good thrives on engaging, relatable content that resonates with younger audiences. They’ve built a brand that extends beyond content into merchandise and partnerships, proving that creator-led production can rival traditional sports media.
The Numbers So Far
TGL Live (2 hours 10 minutes, ESPN Broadcast)
Week 1: 919,000 viewers
Week 2: Over 1 million (Tiger Woods debut)
Week 3: Sharp drop to 682,000 viewers (no Tiger or Rory)
Week 4: Rebound to 864,000 (Tiger Woods vs. Rory McIlroy matchup)
Good Good’s YouTube Match
1 hour run time - 1.1 million views and counting
Tale of the Tape: Let’s Dissect The Production
Courtesy of Dennis Lisberger, Founder of No Red Tape Media, a boutique, social-first content and production company leveraging the creator-led production model through experience working with creators like Dude Perfect, Brodie Smith, F2 Freestylers, Brandon Perna, MMG, Jack Settleman, and Scooter Magruder. Highly relevant, NRT is actively working on People League Golf, collaborating with top golf creators like Luke Kwon, Alexa Melton, Martin Borgmeir, Tooms Golf, Jenna Bandy, and Pointer Bros.
Diving in:
1. Production Value & Broadcast Quality
TGL Live Broadcast (ESPN)
High-budget, premium production with AR overlays and multi-camera setups.
Structured programming with commercial breaks, live commentary, and real-time statistics.
Traditional sports broadcast model.
Good Good’s YouTube Video
Creator-driven, engaging, and organic storytelling.
Prioritizes entertainment and natural player interaction over polished TV aesthetics.
More informal, social-first structure with behind-the-scenes moments and real-time engagement.
2. Audience & Engagement
TGL Live Broadcast
Traditional sports media format with a linear TV & streaming audience.
Limited real-time interaction outside of social media discussions.
Good Good’s YouTube Video
Strong appeal to younger, digital-first golf fans.
On-demand accessibility, leading to higher replay value.
Community-driven engagement, real-time feedback, and direct audience interaction.
3. Content Strategy & Branding
TGL Live Broadcast
Big-event, high-stakes competition with elite golfers.
Celebrity-driven credibility featuring Tiger Woods, Rory McIlroy, and others.
Lacks longevity compared to evergreen social-first content.
Good Good’s YouTube Video
Creator-led, personality-driven storytelling.
Evergreen, shareable content optimized for digital consumption.
Bridges traditional golf and new-generation fan engagement.
Disruptive Play – The Case for Creator-Led Production
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Disruptive Play: Challenging Sports & Media Norms to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.